Is My Husband Overreacting

Question: Dear Luise: My husband and I have been together for a long time but wehave some trust issues. We have kids and own a home, and for the last three years I have been managing all of our finances. Things are tight, and much of our disagreements have to do with money. I was laid off from a good job last year and am on unemployment, and since itdoesn’t look like any jobs in my field will be popping up anytime soon, it looks like I will be full-time caretaker for our kids for the forseeable future. I was a musician in college, and music is my life. In a moment of weakness, I bought a $600 guitar with my own earnings recently. My husband is outraged. Given how tight our budget is, he says I never should have bought it and certainly not without telling him first. He is having my name removed for all our checking accounts and is taking over the finances again as a result. I know it wasn’t a great idea, but the last time I bought a “me” thing (also an instrument) was over 3 years ago, and that used money I got from a small inheritance, not family money. He has been in a fit over this for weeks and says he doesn’t trust me anymore. I have told him that I while I understand why he is upset, I think he is overreacting. All of our bills got paid. He is making both of us miserable, and I have told him I am going to have trust issues with HIM if he goes through with ripping my name out of all our accounts. He says he is just trying to “protect the family.” For the record, I am pretty thrifty generally. I do have a small amount of debt from running a small business, but I am learning as I go, and I have changed some of my policies to put an end to that. I believe I am generally responsible, even if I am not perfect. I feel strongly that if he goes through with cutting me out of all our bank accounts it will create an even bigger chasm between us. He doesn’t see it that way. Your opinion? M.

Answer: Dear M.: My take is that your husband is doing something radical because you did. You had no right to make a unilateral decision like that. It was immature, selfish, shortsighted and dangerous. Tell him you want to get back on solid ground again and will return or sell the instrument. Ask him to meet you half way by not continuing to harp about it. I agree that you can’t be on the accounts. You acted like a child and children don’t have bank accounts. Consider taking a job in a different field, perhaps at less pay. What is probably behind all of his angst is his anxiety over being the only one working and knowing your unemployment is going to run out. Talk to each other about this. Don’t let it undermine your marriage. Blessings, Luise


2 Responses to Is My Husband Overreacting

  1. B. April 16, 2012 at 2:02 pm #

    I totally agree with returning the instrument. B.

  2. W. April 16, 2012 at 9:43 pm #

    I found Mrs. Volta’s response quite harsh. She didn’t kill anyone, she made a purchase that her husband seems to be over reacting to. Yes, they both need to sit down and try to come to some practical solutions, without making this a personal slap in the face to the wife.
    Raising children does involve some work too I imagine. I advice M to open her own accounts.

    Pay all the bills, then each should get a small allowance to save or purchase what they need. Her husband is not her boss, he is her life partner and he needs to roll with her imperfections as she has to do with his.

    Good Luck M!! Hope your husband lightens up, so you don’t have to feel like you need to hide what needs to be openly discussed. W.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: